November 14, 2026
By: Brian Lenney
Senator Kevin Cook and I serve together in the Idaho Senate.
Last month he wrote a column in the Post Register called “App stores must be required to respect parental consent.”
If you didn’t read it, here’s the short version of his argument: Phones are a portal to porn and predators, tech companies have “rigged the system to lock parents out,” and so he’s working on a bill he calls the App Store Protection Act. It would make the app store get a parent’s permission before a kid downloads any app. He says the goal is to “put the keys back in the hands of Idaho parents.”
Kevin means well, and the danger is real. Everyone knows these platforms hurt kids.
But his bill doesn’t touch any of that.
Walk through his column with me and you’ll see it. He says that when our kids hold a smartphone, “they hold a portal to the entire world.”
And there’s the crux of the matter, right?
Why do your kids hold an unlocked smartphone? Who bought it for them? Who pays for the Wi-Fi? Who gives them unsupervised access to the full internet at night? Why do kids need a smartphone in the first place?
They don’t.
The whole argument kind of stops here, I think.
Why would you hand your kid something that can harm them and let them run off with it in their room, or drive off with it with their friends? It’s like handing them a loaded gun and being surprised when someone gets shot.
Kevin says “giant tech corporations operate like digital gatekeepers,” and that parents “must have the final say over what enters their children’s hands.”
But parents already have the final say on what enters their child’s hands, right?
Do children buy a $1,000 iPhone?
Do children pay for Wi-Fi and the internet? No. Mom and Dad do.
The gatekeepers are Mom and Dad, not a tech company. Saying parents are left out of what goes on the phone is like saying they’re left out of who drives the family car. You already make decisions about your family and your kids every day: what’s for dinner, who drives them where, bedtime, screen time, etc.
You don’t need permission to make those decisions.
And you don’t need it here either.
Then he says tech companies “rigged the system to lock parents out.”
This is just fundamentally untrue. Have you ever set up parental controls on an iPhone? I have. It takes like 5 minutes and it’s free. Right now, today, you can make your kid ask permission before downloading any app. That’s the exact thing Kevin’s bill promises, it already exists, and nobody has to show an ID or pass a new law to use it.
Parents are absolutely already in the driver’s seat.
The problem is lazy parents. The problem is parents who don’t want to tell them no. Parents aren’t locked out. Many of them caught up in the same game, zonked out on their phones instead of raising their children (go to a restaraunt and observe).
Kevin says we need “a simple principle of accountability.”
Agreed. Parents should be accountable for the things they give their children. But then he reaches for beer? He says “We don’t blame the farmer who grows barley if a local bar hands beer to a minor,” he writes. But “we do expect the clerk at the store to check an ID.”
This is completely backwards and actually proves too much. In his own sentence, the bar is the one handing beer to a minor. Fine. So why does his bill card kids in the parking lot? If Facebook’s the bar, then his bill never walks inside where underage kids are doing shots. Or, picture a bartender who pours drinks all night and says carding people is “the liquor store’s job.”
That’s his bill.
The clerk analogy doesn’t help either.
Because the gas station only cards for things that are dangerous to kids (cigarettes, nicotine pouches, beer) and it sells you donuts, energy drinks, and the newspaper without a word.
But Kevin’s bill makes everyone upload their government ID before downloading anything at all, from the weather app to the calculator or Bible app.
He calls app stores “the electronic storefronts on our phones” that “make financial transactions with children without asking the parent for permission.”
Except most apps are free, right?
Kids getting harmed on Facebook, Instagram and Snapchat aren’t buying anything, so these aren’t storefronts. And if kids are buying things on a phone without their parents’ permission, the solution is… parents (not big government).
Again, these are not digital storefronts. Because the harm happens at midnight, when a 14-year-old is still in bed scrolling Instagram. But Kevin’s bill is the ticket-taker at a movie theater who checks ages at the door and never checks which theater the kid went into.
If we’re going to hold someone accountable, why don’t we hold someone accountable who’s actually doing the harm? Adult content comes from websites and apps. It doesn’t originate in the device or App Store. A smoke detector only helps if it’s in the room where the fire is. So, in this case, the fire is inside Instagram.
But Kevin’s bill mounts the smoke detector out on the mailbox (the app store) instead.
Then come his bullet points, which promise that parents “give the green light” on every download and get “real legal teeth” if a company ignores them.
All this does is lock the front door while the garage door, side door, back window and sliding glass door are wide open.
What about the laptop?
What about the browser: Safari, Chrome, DuckDuckGo, stuff like that?
What about a friend’s phone or the computer at the library?
All this does is regulate who can download an app. It doesn’t regulate what happens when they do, which is where the real harm happens. If a parent says no to Instagram, the kid can still type instagram.com into a browser and access the same harm. So again, what are we doing here?
Think about what this looks like in real life.
Under this bill your kid needs your approval for every app, from Instagram to the Bible app to the calculator. It’s like signing for every Amazon package that shows up at your door. By Friday you’re signing without looking (and signing never told you what was in the box anyway). Tapping “approve” doesn’t show you what’s inside the app.
As for the legal teeth, Section 8 of the federal version (H.R. 3149) says an app that relied “in good faith” on the age the app store gave it is “deemed not liable.” Translation: when a kid gets hurt, the app points at the app store, and the app store points at Mom, who tapped “approve.”
So besides creating a liability shield for the social media companies doing the harm, all this really accomplishes is the creation of a digital ID checkpoint for every single human being in Idaho (to know who’s a kid, a company has to check who’s an adult, which means checking everybody).
Texas started enforcing its version on June 4, 2026. Now every Texan who opens a new account on the app store has to hand over a credit card or a scan of a government ID (don’t even get me started on data collection here). A federal judge compared it to carding every customer at a bookstore door, but an appeals court let the law take effect anyway.
Kevin says his bill is about “ensuring parents, not multi-billion-dollar corporations, decide what is appropriate for their own children.”
But parents already do this.
The good ones, at least.
No new law or bill needed.
There’s a reason we call this “the Grindr bill” (yes, THAT Grindr, the gay hookup app).
Grindr loves this bill and endorsed the federal version. Meta, Snap and X put out a joint statement cheering Utah’s version. And Pornhub’s parent company is on board with this bill too.

I don’t know what you think, but if there’s a “child safety” bill supported by Meta, Pornhub, and Grindr, I’m running in the other direction.
Kevin closes by saying tech companies shouldn’t get to make contracts with our children “behind our backs.”
Behind our backs is the the problem, right?
What happened to parents… being parents?
I thought Idaho Republicans used to say, “We don’t co-parent with the government.”
I still believe that.











