November 18, 2026
One Small Candle
A Republic, If We Can Keep It
By: Julianne Young

“Thus out of small beginnings greater things have been produced by His hand … as one small candle may light a thousand, so the light here kindled hath shone unto many, yea in some sort to our whole nation.”
— William Bradford, Of Plymouth Plantation, 1630–1650
For centuries, Europe bowed to ruler’s law. The king ruled by divine right; his church the only lawful church. When conscience confronted power, power answered with the dungeon, the rope, and the stake. John Foxe, in his Book of Martyrs, documented thousands, and perhaps tens of thousands, who paid the ultimate price. Persecution ran in every direction: Catholics died under Protestant monarchs, Protestants under Catholic ones. Under Queen Mary alone, nearly 300 were burned. As the flames rose at Oxford in 1555, Hugh Latimer turned to his fellow prisoner: “Be of good comfort, Master Ridley, and play the man. We shall this day light such a candle, by God’s grace, in England, as I trust shall never be put out.”
In April 1632, officers raided John Lathrop’s secret worship service in London and marched forty-two of his congregation to prison for worshiping outside the established church. While others were freed on bail, Lathrop, who refused an oath acknowledging the king as head of the church, was judged too dangerous. He languished in prison as his wife, Hannah, sickened and died; tradition holds that his children begged bread in London’s streets. Unable to break him and unwilling to make a martyr of him, the authorities released him on condition that he leave England.
Lathrop, his children, and about thirty of his congregation sailed to join the Pilgrims, who in 1620 had changed the course of history by rejecting ruler’s law and covenanting to “combine ourselves together into a civil body politic” to frame “just and equal laws.” The Mayflower Compact held high a flame that would shine to all the world: authority rises from the consent of the governed, and law binds those who govern as surely as the governed. By the time the Pilgrims gave thanks in 1621, they had buried half their company in the frozen ground. Yet, warmed by a light that burned within, they stayed, and they gave thanks.
Their sacrifice was no endpoint. Two centuries later, Elijah P. Lovejoy, a Presbyterian minister and newspaper editor, was driven from St. Louis for condemning slavery. Refusing to be silenced, he moved his press across the river to Alton, Illinois. Three times mobs destroyed it. A few defended his right to a free press. Others, even fellow churchgoers, blamed him for stirring up trouble, and most washed their hands of him. Days before his martyrdom, he told the town, “If the civil authorities refuse to protect me, I must look to God; and if I die, I have determined to make my grave in Alton.” On November 7, 1837, defending his fourth press and the principle that no man should own another, he was shot dead. Like the tyrants of Europe, his killers refused to answer arguments with reason, and instead silenced reason with force. And like the Pilgrims’ sacrifice, his would bear fruit in time.
The struggle continues worldwide. Freedom House reports that just 21 percent of the world’s people now live in countries rated Free. Open Doors counts 388 million Christians facing intense persecution for their faith.
Nor is this challenge confined to distant lands. In any contest of opinions, especially over right and wrong, some prefer to prevail, not through reason, but through intimidation and force. Factions form, guided not by loyalty to principle but by political protectionism. Those on the “outside” are enemies, not because of genuine disagreements, but because they won’t bow to top-down power. Like kings and the king’s men, more interested in control than the public good, they seek to silence those whose independent views threaten their objectives.
Thankfully, today’s tools of political intimidation are usually less deadly. The aim remains the same. The tell: something is amiss whenever political questions are answered with polarizing labels and character attacks rather than arguments grounded in truth, reason, and principle.
As the Constitutional Convention came to a close in 1787, Benjamin Franklin was asked what had been created. “A republic,” he replied, “if you can keep it.” Franklin understood that parchment cannot keep a republic. Citizens do: those who meet argument with reasoned argument, who defend a neighbor’s right to disagree, and who refuse to trade principle for a seat on the inside.
This Thanksgiving, as we bow our heads over full tables, let us remember the candle Latimer lit at Oxford, carried by Lathrop across the Atlantic, and defended by Lovejoy at Alton. It cannot keep itself. The responsibility rests in our hands.
Julianne Young is a Bingham County Mom who loves faith, family, and freedom; a former state representative; founder of the nonprofit Idaho Family Strong; regional coordinator for Idaho Chooses Life; and 2nd Vice Chair of the Idaho State GOP.











